What we’ve heard from people living in West Yorkshire

smiling people visiting the Healthwatch Leeds stall at a Pride event. A lady in the foreground in a mobility scooter has a rainbow flag draped over her shoulders.Listening to what people and communities tell us is important. This has been central to the development of all work, including this  strategy. As a Partnership we have ongoing conversations with people and communities living in West Yorkshire, supported by Healthwatch partners as set out in our Involvement Framework and the work of our local places.

As part of the development of this strategy, a number of reports summarising what people are telling us is their experience of health and care have been produced. This includes a Healthwatch Insight Report published in August 2022, a mapping report published in May 2022 setting out involvement and consultation activity across West Yorkshire and lastly a further mapping report from across the Partnership. This provides oversight of engagement in all other areas of work. This is produced every year.

Halifax diabetes stall - a group of men and women standing under a gazebo with 'NHS' on it and behind a table that says 'Diabetes UK' with leaflets on it.A number of themes have been raised over the last year (2022) as a result of these discussions in relation to healthcare across West Yorkshire. The changing context has in many cases placed a new emphasis on some of the themes and more recently the cost-of- living crisis has been an escalating issue.

Access to primary care remains a key area of concern. Primary care is considered the front door to the wider health and care service and many feel let down when they can’t access their GP in a way that works for them. There is a deep concern that this has a negative impact on their health and wellbeing.

Access to dentistry services continues to be an issue raised for both children and adults. This is both in terms of being able to register with an NHS dentist and access to appointments and treatment when registered. It was also raised that access to urgent dental care was not as responsive as needed.

“I moved here six months before the pandemic, and I have been unable to find an NHS dentist taking on patients”.

Bradford District Care NHS Foundation Trust staff deliver a dental hygiene session in a schoolOf increasing concern is the cost-of-living crisis which continues to escalate and impact on people’s lives. This impacts significantly on their ability to make choices that positively impact their wellbeing, such as accessing healthcare, undertaking activities that support mental wellbeing, eating healthy nutritious food and being able to live in warm, safe housing. These challenges are having a particular impact on those who are living with social disadvantage, serious illness, addictions and those people who are carers.

We know that suicide rates rise during times of economic recessions and financial exclusion is a significant risk factor in suicide deaths.

“Currently the cost of living is causing a lot of problems in the local area and we’re seeing a dramatic increase in the number of members that come to us for support around bills, particularly utility bills. We have heard stories about people choosing whether they’re heating or eating, which is really difficult. At the moment the sun is shining, so that will be less of a problem, but as the year goes on and the winter nights come in and things get colder, this is going to be more difficult for people”.

A man holding a glass jar in one hand and the lid in another. A label on the jar reads Labels are for jars. Not for people!There continues to be concern around accessing support for mental health in a timely manner, an issue which has increased with the impact of the pandemic. Of significant concern is access to support for our children and young people and the level of support for children who are waiting for assessment for, or have been diagnosed with, autism. Self-harm rates are rising, and the people we are supporting with mental health issues are becoming more unwell, more quickly than they have previously.

We know that the pandemic has led to significant delays in treatment, particularly for planned care services, and people are telling us that this is causing a deterioration in their physical, mental and emotional health. The impact of this is also extending to family members and carers.

The choice people have in accessing care that is right for them highlighted concerns about digital exclusion with many appointments and support moving to online. Many of our population do not have access to digital technology or have additional challenges in using it. This was particularly a challenge for people with learning disabilities.

Negative experiences of quality of care are starting to emerge in some care settings. Whilst it is acknowledged that this is in part due to challenges arising from the pandemic in terms of staff shortages, it is still important to be treated with care and compassion.

We know that children and young people from ethnic minority backgrounds and those in more deprived areas with diabetes have consistently poorer blood sugar control. We also recognise that there is a variation in access to digital technology such as continuous glucose monitoring.

“People (who don’t speak English) rely on families to help make the appointments, but sometimes after a long wait they are told to call back the next day as no appointments are available”.

“My GP surgery is very good. I can get a face-to-face appt to check my blood pressure and weight and if I’m told a GP will ring me back, they do. I rang once on a Friday and was offered an appointment on Monday but when I explained it was for my mental health she said, ‘oh no we can’t leave it until Monday’ and she got me a GP appointment for the same day. I can’t praise my surgery enough”.

A group of women at a boxercise class in Wakefield

Dr James Thomas

Dr Sohail Abbas